Been thinking a lot about this as well, Adam. Being critical enough to recognize flaws within, and perhaps even become disillusioned with, our present systems for healthcare, education, science etc. while also reminding myself that I fundamentally believe in the value of science (and the benefit of pooling collective resources for it) in a well-functioning society is a difficult balance to strike! But perhaps what people need to believe is a dream for a better future? Not just a warning of a possible nightmare scenario. Not sure yet what that would look like…
Thanks Lily! I guess I'd just add that "our present systems" are a moving target, currently in a rapid state of decline. I'd hope we could recognize the flaws they had before and imagine improving them if/when we get the chance, while also recognizing their successes and trying to keep what works. As opposed to overturning everything in a big hurry for nakedly political reasons, as seems to be happening now.
Thanks Jed! Writing about Sumner is also way more fun for me (but FWIW the audience for it seems to be much smaller. I get way more clicks of every kind for screeds about the besiegement of U.S. science).
Been thinking a lot about this as well, Adam. Being critical enough to recognize flaws within, and perhaps even become disillusioned with, our present systems for healthcare, education, science etc. while also reminding myself that I fundamentally believe in the value of science (and the benefit of pooling collective resources for it) in a well-functioning society is a difficult balance to strike! But perhaps what people need to believe is a dream for a better future? Not just a warning of a possible nightmare scenario. Not sure yet what that would look like…
Thanks Lily! I guess I'd just add that "our present systems" are a moving target, currently in a rapid state of decline. I'd hope we could recognize the flaws they had before and imagine improving them if/when we get the chance, while also recognizing their successes and trying to keep what works. As opposed to overturning everything in a big hurry for nakedly political reasons, as seems to be happening now.
So well said. And such a bummer. Thank you for this. (Though it’s more fun to read about Sumner!)
Thanks Jed! Writing about Sumner is also way more fun for me (but FWIW the audience for it seems to be much smaller. I get way more clicks of every kind for screeds about the besiegement of U.S. science).